About Civil.ge
Eng | Geo | Rus
Last updated: 16:42 - 16 Oct.'17
RSS
Mobile
Twitter
Facebook
Two of Three Georgian Nominees for Vacant ECHR Judge Position Rejected
Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 26 Jul.'17 / 13:22

The Council of Europe Advisory Panel of Experts said in its conclusion that only one out of three candidates for a vacant position of Georgia-nominated judge to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) meets the criteria set by the European Convention, Georgian Justice Minister Tea Tsulukiani said on July 25.
 
Tsulukiani said that Lado Chanturia, former chairman of the Georgia’s Supreme Court, will continue selection procedures and added that a competition will be announced to select the remaining two candidates, as Shota Getsadze and Sophio Japaridze failed to meet the criteria due to lack of judicial practice and professional experience.
 
The nationwide procedures for selecting three three candidates for vacant ECHR judge position have been underway since December 2015. In January 2017, the Committee on the Election of Judges to ECHR, special committee of the Council of Europe’s Parliamentary Assembly, rejected three Georgia-nominated candidates to ECHR, citing lack of qualifications, prompting the Government of Georgia to announce a new call for applications in February.
 
In May 2017, the 13-member selection commission under the Justice Ministry shortlisted five candidates, three of whom were later approved by the government and presented to an international Advisory Panel of Council of Europe experts, which offers nominating governments confidential advice on potential candidates before the final list of three is sent to the Assembly.
 
The Georgian President’s administration, opposition parties and civil society representatives criticized the commission’s choice, saying the impartiality of commission members “raises questions.”
 
The Coalition for Independent and Transparent Judiciary, including civil society organizations which participated in the selection process, demanded annulment of the competition results.
 
“Due to the purposeful actions of government representatives, some highly competent and reputable candidates failed to make it to the list of top five and then top three candidates, whereas candidates with questionable qualifications and reputation made it into the group,” the coalition said in its statement released on July 3.
 
Georgia has to submit the list of three candidates to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) before August 31. Once the Assembly receives the list of the three nominees, the Committee on the Election of Judges to the European Court of Human Rights will interview each of the three candidates in person and will scrutinize their CVs, in a standardized format, before recommending whether or not to accept the list – in other words, whether it believes all three candidates are sufficiently well qualified to do the job. If so, it will indicate which candidates it believes are the strongest. If not, authorities will be asked to submit a new list.
 
The Assembly - made up of 324 parliamentarians - then proceeds to vote on the candidates in a secret ballot, held during plenary sessions, based on the committee recommendations. An absolute majority of votes cast is required in the first round. If this is not achieved, a second round is held and the candidate with the most votes is duly elected to serve on the Court for a non-renewable term of nine years.
 
The Strasbourg-based European Court of Human Rights rules on individual or state applications alleging violations of the civil and political rights set out in the European Convention on Human Rights.
 
The tenure of Nona Tsotsoria, current Georgia-nominated ECHR judge, expired in January 2017, but was prolonged due to the PACE committee rejection of Georgia-nominated candidates.

Latest News
16 Oct.'17 16:42
Georgian, Italian Presidents Meet, Discuss Bilateral Cooperation
Giorgi Margvelashvili will also hold a meeting with Pietro Grasso, President of the Senate of the Republic.
14 Oct.'17 08:59
U.S. Embassy on Constitutional Amendments
The Parliament overturned the presidential objections on the draft constitution at today’s plenary sitting.
13 Oct.'17 22:21
Parliament Overrides Presidential Veto on Constitutional Amendments
The ruling party approved the initial version of the draft constitution with 117 votes.
13 Oct.'17 12:09
Georgian MFA on Catalonia Developments
Tbilisi rejects unilateral declarations of independence.
13 Oct.'17 11:09
Georgian Leaders Discuss Russian Occupation, Strategic Priorities
President, Prime Minister and Parliament Chairman address the annual security conference in Batumi.
12 Oct.'17 17:31
41st Round of Geneva International Discussions
The Georgian and Russian sides present their grievances at the latest round of talks.
11 Oct.'17 18:12
Red Cross Identifies Remains of Abkhazia Conflict Victims
The identification took place within the Red Cross coordination mechanism, launched in 2010.
11 Oct.'17 17:22
Georgia Hosts South-East Europe Defense Ministerial
Georgia joined the regional defense and security cooperation platform in 2015
11 Oct.'17 12:41
Non-Parliamentary Parties Concerned over ‘Discriminatory, Uneven’ Election Environment
Thirteen opposition parties released a joint appeal to international and local observer organizations.
11 Oct.'17 11:45
Opposition Continues Protests on Transfer of Lands to Panorama Tbilisi
United National Movement announced its plans to organize a large-scale rally on October 14.

About Civil Georgia
Civil.Ge © 2001-2017, Daily News Online
Registered office: 2 Dolidze Str, 4-th Floor.
67