About Civil.ge
Eng | Geo | Rus
Last updated: 03:02 - 12 Dec.'17
Georgia's Case vs. Russia Fails to Proceed on Merits in ICJ
Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 1 Apr.'11 / 13:27

President of the International Court of Justice, Judge Hasishi Owada, was reading the Court’s judgment into Russia’s objections at the Peace Palace in The Hague for more than an hour on April 1. Photo: Courtesy ICJ/Fotoburo Dijkstra BV/Peter Brom

Having upheld one of the Russian Federation’s preliminary objections, the Hague-based International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled on April 1, that Georgia’s case against Russia “can not proceed to the merit phase.”

By ten votes to six the Court found that “it has no jurisdiction to entertain the application filed by Georgia on the 12th of August, 2008”, President of the International Court of Justice, Judge Hasishi Owada, announced at a public sitting of the court. 

  • Georgia's Reaction to ICJ's Ruling
  • Russia's Reaction to ICJ's Ruling 

    In its case filed before ICJ more than two years ago, Georgia claimed that Russia violated its obligations under the 1965 International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD) during three distinct phases of its interventions in South Ossetia and Abkhazia in the period from 1990 to August 2008.

    But before the Court moved to consideration of the application on its merit, the Russian Federation in December, 2009 filed its preliminary objections arguing that ICJ had no jurisdiction to hear the case.

    Russia’s claim was based on several arguments; one of them argued that there had been “no dispute” between Tbilisi and Moscow over racial discrimination against the ethnic Georgian population of Abkhazia and South Ossetia and that Tbilisi had never formally raised the issue directly with Moscow.

    This argument was rejected by ICJ saying that “by the day on which Georgia submitted this application there was a dispute” between the two countries about Russia’s compliance with the obligations under CERD.
    Another argument put forth by Russia to claim that ICJ had no jurisdiction to hear the case on merits was related with procedures as defined in Article 22 of CERD; Russia argued that before going directly to ICJ, Georgia should have at first raised the issue before the UN’s Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination and should have engaged in negotiations with Moscow on the matter.

    The Court upheld this argument by Moscow and said that Georgia neither attempted to negotiate specifically CERD-related matters with the Russian Federation nor used other mode of dispute resolution contained in Article 22 before referring the case directly to ICJ.

    ICJ’s April 1 ruling comes after it held public hearings into Russia’s preliminary objections in September, 2010.

  • Latest News
    12 Dec.'17 03:02
    Judge Releases Saakashvili from Courtroom
    The prosecution sought placing the ex-President of Georgia to pre-trial house arrest for two months.
    11 Dec.'17 17:02
    Parliament Speaker: Election of President by 300-member Electoral College ‘Will Remain In Force’
    Kobakhidze says the system has shortcomings, but the ruling party will keep it as ‘a political compromise.’
    11 Dec.'17 12:37
    Q3’17 FDI USD 594 mln – Preliminary Data
    Most of the FDI in the third quarter of 2017 came from Azerbaijan, followed Turkey and the United Kingdom.
    09 Dec.'17 17:19
    Friends of Georgia Group Stresses Support in the Face of Russian Occupation
    The group of countries addresses ethnic discrimination, Russian military build-up among other issues.
    09 Dec.'17 12:39
    Ukrainian National Police Detains Saakashvili
    Ex-President Mikheil Saakashvili went on a hunger strike, might face house arrest.
    08 Dec.'17 18:08
    Georgia in OSCE Ministerial Council Statements
    Several foreign ministers spoke on Georgia in their addresses at the 24th OSCE Ministerial Council.
    08 Dec.'17 16:04
    FM Janelidze Addresses OSCE Ministerial Council
    Mikheil Janelidze lists violations in the occupied territories, calls for Europe without spheres of influence.
    08 Dec.'17 10:34
    Georgia ‘Closely Monitoring’ Jerusalem Developments, Foreign Ministry Says
    The statement follows the request of a ruling party lawmaker to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.
    07 Dec.'17 23:44
    Parliament Endorses PM’s Structural Reform Plan
    The Government-proposed amendments bill envisages the merger and reorganization of several ministries.
    07 Dec.'17 17:48
    CSOs Concerned over Ukraine’s Decision to Deny Entry to Georgian Journalists
    Journalists from Rustavi 2, TV Pirveli and the Public Broadcaster were refused entry into Ukraine.

    About Civil Georgia
    Civil.Ge © 2001-2017, Daily News Online
    Registered office: 2 Dolidze Str, 4-th Floor.