About Civil.ge
Eng | Geo | Rus
Last updated: 14:48 - 22 Apr.'17
RSS
Mobile
Twitter
Facebook
Group Criticizes Draft of Constitutional Amendments
Civil Georgia, Tbilisi / 24 Jul.'10 / 14:59

Draft of constitutional amendments came under fire from a group of legal experts and civil society representatives united in an organization known as public constitutional commission, saying that the proposed draft does not provide increase of parliamentary powers, as claimed by its authors.

Authors of the draft of constitutional amendments, developed by the state commission on constitutional reform, say it would provide "mixed governance" where the President will act as "an arbiter" between the legislative body and executive government, led by Prime Minister elected from the ranks of a party, which will garner most of the votes in the parliamentary elections.

Member of the state commission and a senior ruling party lawmaker, Pavle Kublashvili, who supported the draft, said that the amendments will secure creation of “a mixed system, more inclined towards the parliamentary system.”

In parallel to the state commission, an alternative group – public constitutional commission - was established last year by figures, mainly those critical to the authorities, to develop a draft of the new constitution.

Mindia Ugrekhelidze, a former chairman of the Georgian Supreme Court and a member of the public constitutional commission, said the draft, proposed by the state commission, created an impression that it would increase Parliament’s powers, but in fact no substantial change would occur.

In a statement on July 23 the public constitutional commission said that the draft would leave the Parliament as “powerless, as it is now.” The commission, however, also acknowledges that the exception is the case when a government is being formed after the parliamentary election, when the source of formation of the executive branch is the Parliament. Otherwise, the commission said, it would still be “easy to dissolve” the Parliament if the latter decides to pass vote of no confidence.

The commission says most of the powers will still remain under the executive branch with only difference that instead of the President, as it is now, it will be the Prime Minister, who will hold most of the authority.

The public constitutional commission also criticized the draft for keeping the rule under which governors in the provinces are appointed and not elected. Under the proposed draft governors will be appointed by Prime Minister, instead of President as currently.

The public constitutional commission also stresses that the proposed draft does not provide increased rights for opposition in the Parliament and says that setting up of investigative or other type of ad hoc commission will still remain solely on the will of the ruling majority. The proposed draft simplifies the process of initiation of setting up of investigative commission, as one fifth of lawmakers, instead of current one fourth, will be needed for that purpose.

The public constitutional commission also complained that the draft did not address measures required for “creating free and fair election environment”
 
The public commission also criticized decision to remove category of organic law from the draft of constitutional amendments. For passing in the Parliament organic laws require higher quorum, than ordinary laws. The commission members said that by removing this category of laws, the government was paving way for easier option of passing legislature in the Parliament.

Latest News
22 Apr.'17 14:48
Georgia in CoE Annual Report on Democracy
The Council of Europe Secretary General’s fourth annual report was released on April 20.
22 Apr.'17 12:13
NGOs Criticize Constitution Draft, Propose Further Debate
NGOs propose final debate, criticizing the draft constitution amendments.
22 Apr.'17 00:26
Opposition Parties Reject Constitution Changes, Boycott Commission
The final meeting of the Constitutional Reform Commission is to be held on April 22.
21 Apr.'17 14:10
CoE Issues Report on Conflict in Georgia
The Ministers’ Deputies of the Council of Europe member states held a debate on this topic on April 19.
21 Apr.'17 01:49
President Slams Draft Constitution Amendments
Margvelashvili views the ongoing reform process as an attempt to curtail the presidency.
20 Apr.'17 23:50
PM Kvirikashvili on Georgia’s Foreign, Security Policy
Prime Minister Giorgi Kvirikashvili addressed the fourth South Caucasus Security Forum on April 20.
20 Apr.'17 17:55
Foreign Minister on Reintegration, Abkhazia Railway Opening
Mikheil Janelidze outlined Tbilisi’s strategy towards the occupied regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
20 Apr.'17 16:13
Georgian Defense Minister: France ‘Strategic Ally’
French, Georgian defense ministers outline ‘cooperation plan’ to strengthen Georgia’s air defense.
20 Apr.'17 03:30
Sergey Lavrov Reassures Sokhumi on Security
Sergey Lavrov spoke on transit connection to Armenia through the region, non-use of force agreement.
19 Apr.'17 14:40
Iranian Foreign Minister Concludes Georgia Visit
Prime Minister Giorgi Kvirikashvili will visit Tehran on April 22-23.

About Civil Georgia
Civil.Ge © 2001-2017, Daily News Online
Registered office: 2 Dolidze Str, 4-th Floor.
9